Monday, June 20, 2005
Over There, Online
AMERICAN INVESTORS INCREASINGLY ARE HEEDING the long-time advice to diversify their portfolios internationally. In the past, that’s meant mutual funds, most of which carry fairly hefty expenses. As with domestic funds, exchange-traded funds have been making major inroads in the global arena. A glance at the size rankings of ETFs shows that the iShares MSCI EAFE Index Fund (ticker: EFA), is No. 3, surpassed only by the Standard & Poor’s Depositary Receipts (SPY) and the Nasdaq 100 Trust (QQQQ).
EFA, which tracks the Morgan Stanley Capital International EAFE (Europe, Australasia and the Far East) Index, provides exposure to the globe’s developed (as opposed to emerging) markets in one fell swoop. And since exchange-traded funds can be bought and sold throughout the trading day, just like a stock, it’s easy to trade. Its expense ratio is a low 0.35%, making it an attractive buy, especially compared with mutual funds that invest abroad, which have an average expense ratio of 1.77%.
THERE IS ALSO AN ARRAY of ETFs that each provide exposure to a single country—say Brazil, or South Korea—as well as regional indexes, which give individuals an efficient means to pinpoint opportunities around the globe.
At MSN Money (http://www.moneycentral.msn.com), check out the ETF section, found under mutual funds. There you’ll find a complete list of exchange-traded funds, broken down by category, including non-U.S., global and emerging-market funds. On the main ETF page, enter a ticker to get a snapshot of a fund from Thomson Financial.
In addition, at MarketWatch (http://www.marketwatch.com), you check the ETF Center. There, the Quick Screener breaks down funds by regions, among other criteria. (Like Barron’s, MarketWatch is published by Dow Jones.)
So far, there aren’t any international fixed-income ETFs, but there are several closed-end funds in this category, most of which trade at a discount. (We’ll examine resources for closed-ends in a future issue.)
There’s more to investing in international equities, of course, than buying and selling ETFs of other funds. Several dozen Barron’s readers responded to our requests for their wish lists and gripes concerning the subject. As always, I’m impressed by the thoughtful responses crafted by those who wrote to our online mailbox; thanks to all of you who took the time to share your thoughts.
Quite a few readers of this column have given international trading a go, only to run into obstacles.
Only one online broker earned a grudging compliment; the rest were found wanting. Among the problems: an inability to submit limit orders in foreign currencies to be executed in foreign markets, and the lack of visible and predictable commission schedules on foreign currency exchanges. Unlike the U.S., where public companies face shareholder-communication requirements, some other lands impose no such rules. Our intrepid explorers found that it is difficult to learn about corporate reorganizations or to get copies of annual reports.
Interactive Brokers (http://www.interactivebrokers.com) has a lot to offer investors in foreign shares. Its “Trader Workstation” provides direct access to stocks, options, futures, foreign exchanges and bonds that can be bought and sold in more than 50 markets in 14 countries, with more on the way. IB’s wide range of offerings and low fees earned it the top spot among direct-access brokers in Barron’s 2005 review of online brokers ("Speed or Comfort,” March 7.)
To trade abroad, a U.S.-based customer would open an account in dollars, then generate a margin loan in the foreign currency. To eliminate the loan, the customer has to trade currencies through the IB IDEAL network, or deposit funds in another currency.
One Barron’s reader who responded to our e-mail request for comment on international-trading experiences said he had executed more than 100 trades since opening his account last fall, and noted that IB offers, “very low commissions, powerful trading software with available data feeds from many countries, excellent currency contracts, low-cost margin and three types of excellent help services.”
On the downside, our reader comments that IB seems interested in professional traders, not amateurs. He says that the company’s software is solid, frequently upgraded with features that clients ask for, and is very flexible, with quite a bit of trade-oriented reporting—but it doesn’t have much in the way of long-term investment analysis, or links to research. “It’s called Trader Workstation, with the emphasis on Trader,” he concludes.
Several readers who have traded Canadian stocks are customers of TD Waterhouse (http://www.tdwaterhouse.com), owned by Toronto-Dominion, the big north-of-the-border bank. One wrote in with a list of pros and cons. Prominent among the cons was that a customer couldn’t trade Canadian securities online—orders must be placed by phone, and charges are higher than they would be if the transaction is done over the Internet.
Several Charles Schwab (http://www.schwab.com) customers complained about buying or selling shares through its international desk, because they had to do so by phone and pay fees that they viewed as on the high side.
A Uruguay-based Schwab customer complimented the firm’s Spanish-language assistance, noting that he had tried to open an Ameritrade (http://www.ameritrade.com) account as well, but ended up closing it, owing to a lack of help in Spanish. However, this customer complained about Schwab’s lack of transparency in online bond trading, lack of international bonds and lack of currency trading. Plus, as noted, the international trades had to be conducted over the phone, rather than online.
E*Trade has branded Websites in 12 countries. Outside the U.S., those sites let customers trade in their own local markets, as well as on U.S. exchanges. But Americans still can’t “cross the borders” and place trades on foreign exchanges.
JARRETT LILIEN, E*TRADE’S president and chief operating officer, plans to launch an International Center on the Website that is similar to the existing exchange-traded fund center. He says that customers will be able to get quotes and content, and information on American depositary receipts and international ETFs. “Eventually, we’ll have direct access to international markets on that tab,” Lilien adds.
Lilien came to E*Trade in 1999, after it purchased his firm, TIR Securities. TIR was headquartered in Hong Kong, and focused on the institutional markets, with trades being placed on 35 exchanges around the world. He says that 68% of E*Trade customers surveyed said they’d like to place international trades, and he likens the current interest in international trading to that in options just a few years ago.
According to Lilien, E*Trade’s current infrastructure, with internal order-routing, gives it a direct connection to the exchanges. Before year’s end, he would like to add five or six global markets where customers can have direct access, and is considering Canada, the U.K., Germany, France, Hong Kong and Japan. His vision is to offer direct access to all global markets, and to facilitate trading and investing on local exchanges.
Published in Barron’s June 20, 2005